Arts and business news from around the country.


Friday Is the New Tuesday, and Other Observations on the “New Normal” in the Nonprofit Arts Sector

Posted by Eileen Cunniffe

In the waning days of 2013, an article in the Philadelphia Inquirer cited examples of performing arts organizations experimenting with curtain times, holding some weeknight performances as early as 6:30 pm instead of the long-accepted standard of 8:00 pm. The reasons given included appealing to younger audiences, who might want to go somewhere else after the show; appealing to older audiences, who might appreciate getting home earlier; and appealing to everyone in between, who might find it easier to hire a babysitter or just to show up for work the next day. One of the early trends from this experimentation is that some midweek performances with earlier curtain times are pulling even with or outpacing once-hot Friday evening ticket sales.


In other words, Friday is the new Tuesday—or maybe Tuesday is the new Friday? Either way, this is as good a place as any to begin the conversation about what constitutes the “new normal” for the nonprofit arts and culture sector and how arts organizations continue to respond to the changing environment in terms of audience behaviors and, in the wake of the Great Recession, evolving funder behaviors, too.


Looking back at 2013, it was in many ways a year of contradictory trends in the arts sector: two steps forward, one step back, or perhaps the other way around. Growth, contraction, innovation, struggle, resurrection, collapse.


Consider these findings gleaned from the 2013 Americans for the Arts (AFTA) National Arts Index and previous AFTA research, as reported in this NPQ newswire:


  • Between 2000 and 2010, the number of new nonprofit arts organizations grew 49 percent faster than all nonprofit organizations, which grew 32 percent. This trend continued during the recession—3,000 new nonprofit arts organizations were created between 2007 and 2009.
  • Even while that was occurring, mainstream nonprofit arts organization attendance was declining.
  • In 2011, 18,000 arts organizations lost their nonprofit status in the IRS crackdown.


In a recent article in the GIA Reader from Grantmakers in the Arts, Rebecca Thomas of the Nonprofit Finance Fund notes, “Most of our nonprofit clients deeply understand the artistic implications of their broken business models and diminished balance sheets.”

So how are they responding?


Audience retention and development, which often directly generate earned revenue, matter more than ever. And in a wired world where audiences have every opportunity to express their opinions and state their preferences, tweaking curtain times is one way to show responsiveness. Experimenting with smaller venues, shorter performances, public pop-up concerts and “random acts of culture” are other ways arts organizations have been attempting to attract new audiences, as reported in this NPQ newswire that focused on innovative opera companies. Cross-pollination, collaboration and audience participation were cited as keys to success in this report about lessons learned from a poetry festival in Miami. And squeezing a little culture into the lunch hour—or a happy hour—as in “A Play, a Pie and a Pint” is a model that’s gaining traction internationally.


Other new realities in the arts sector have been much harder to navigate: reduced staff sizes, shifts in funding patterns, an alarming reduction in arts education in public schools, and increasing attention to capitalization and cash flow. And while there are signs of resilience and perseverance within the sector, there are also plenty of examples of longstanding cultural institutions that have already failed, or are quite publicly struggling to weather the storm. The Americans for the Arts 2013 Arts Index shows that larger cultural institutions—especially museums and those in the performing arts—are still, in effect, in recession, as reported here.


Consider the long-running standoff between the Minnesota Orchestral Association and its musicians, documented over the last many months in these NPQ newswires. Or consider all the other major orchestras—including those in Atlanta, Baltimore, Cleveland, Dallas, Detroit, Philadelphia and Pittsburgh—that have struggled with structural deficits, union-management issues and/or bankruptcy since the recession began.


Consider the demise of the New York City Opera, which some consider a suicide, or at least a preventable tragedy, for which a last-ditch effort at crowdfunding was too little too late.


Or consider these reports of asset-rich but cash-poor museums in Baltimore, in Chicago, in Pittsburgh, and in Washington, D.C. – where board, staff, and funders are all wrestling with sustainability issues and, in many cases, fiduciary lapses.


Of course, structural tensions around funding were evident within the sector long before the economy began falling apart in 2008. Still, there was some modest evidence in 2013 to suggest that funding of the arts may be on the rebound, as reported in this NPQ newswire: Giving USA 2013 found that arts and culture was America’s fastest-growing philanthropic cause in 2012, and the Americans for the Arts’ BCA National Survey of Business Support for the Arts showed an increase of 18 percent in business giving to the cultural sector from 2009 to 2012, after downward trends in 2006 and 2009. However, both reports came with asterisks: the BCA survey demonstrated that business support for the arts had rebounded to “near 2006 levels,” leaving plenty of lost ground to be made up. And as noted in the Los Angeles Times following the release of Giving USA, a peek behind the curtain of data showing increased support for the cultural sector suggested that many donors still don’t see the arts as essential to society, which is why their gifts went elsewhere during the peak years of the recession.


Fortunately, many funders do appreciate the larger implications for society of investing in the arts. To cite just a few examples:


  • The Kresge Foundation sees “arts and culture as central to discussions of rebuilding and reinvigorating metropolitan areas as land use, housing, transportation, economic development and other more traditional disciplines.” In fact, this trend to invest in “creative placemaking,” which has been picking up steam in recent years is a bright spot for the cultural sector and recognizes that artists and arts organizations are vital to communities. It fosters collaboration between arts organizations, and sometimes between arts groups and other sectors, like small businesses, as reported here
  • The Knight Arts initiative of the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation continues to invest in community-building arts projects in eight metropolitan areas. Knight has for the last few years supported the aforementioned “Random Acts of Culture,” and more recently has launched “Library Acts of Culture.” Knight invests not only in nonprofit arts groups, but also in projects led by individual artists or by start-ups that are not 501(c)(3) organizations. This type of project-based funding aims to foster entrepreneurial—and sometimes transient—art-making, collaboration, and community engagement. This is a departure from the traditional foundation model of funding only nonprofit arts organizations, and it reflects a broader movement afoot in the creative sector, especially among younger artists who would rather take their chances with project grants and crowdfunding than taking on the responsibilities of managing a nonprofit entity.
  • PNC Arts Alive is a three-region, multi-year arts funding program from a corporate funder named to the 2013 BCA 10: Best Businesses Partnering with the Arts in America. The focus of these grants is to support performing and visual arts organizations with innovative approaches to expanding audience participation and engagement. In other words, investing in efforts that are likely to retain and develop audiences over time, making the grantees more self-sustaining.


NPQ also reported during 2013 on a number of arts institutions that seemed to be successfully reinventing themselves following fiscal or other crises. While the jury may still be out on the long-term sustainability of these organizations, their “comeback” stories offer hope—and hopefully some wisdom—to those still struggling to regroup:



In summary, those who work in, volunteer for, fund, patronize, or otherwise contribute to the nonprofit arts sector had some reasons to celebrate in 2013. The worst effects of the economic downturn seem to be fading into the rearview mirror. Which is not to say there haven’t been casualties, or that there will not be others. But new models are emerging, and while some of these may represent departures from traditional nonprofit structures, they may in fact be good for the arts community—and society—as a whole, if they are nimble and responsive enough to keep evolving as the environment changes. In the meantime, the concept of capitalization—which can hardly be separated from the concept of sustainability for many existing arts organizations—is perhaps the theme that most deserves the attention of the sector as we enter 2014.


(This article, originally posted on Nonprofit Quarterly, is one in a weekly series highlighting the pARTnership Movement, Americans for the Arts’ campaign to reach business leaders with the message that partnering with the arts can build their competitive advantage.)


*This article was posted on ARTSblog.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More News

Listen Up, Drink Up
Mar 20, 2018 0 Comments
2016 BCA 10 Winner Dogfish Head Craft Brewery (DE) has an impressive history of supporting and collaborating with the music industry. As part of their Off-Centered Art Series, Dogfish Head Brewery creates seasonal beers. In honor...
Go to full post
360 Degrees of Dance, Design, and Technology
Mar 15, 2018 0 Comments
Last week, Barney’s New York, Samsung Electronics America, and Martha Graham Dance Company unveiled the new Window on Madison Ave. Combining fashion, tech, and art, the display offers passersby, shoppers, and art enthusiasts...
Go to full post
NYC Business Provides World Class Platform for Youth Creativity
Mar 01, 2018 0 Comments
Everyone faces challenges; but not everyone has the tools to overcome them. What happens when companies provide resources and recognition to young people to work through these issues in creative, safe spaces? Change.   Scholastic...
Go to full post
Art & Water: The Two Essentials
Feb 22, 2018 0 Comments
It’s been a year since we featured LIFEWTR for their collaboration with artists for the design on their bottles of purified water. The company believes that its dynamic bottle labels is what will give the brand an edge over its...
Go to full post
Hospitality for the Arts
Feb 20, 2018 0 Comments
When searching for hotels, people are drawn to places that exude a sense of intention and creativity. A hotel’s aesthetics thus play a key role in its success –  as an industry, the hospitality world already has a need to be...
Go to full post
For Artists, By Artists: Supporting Each Other Through Business
Feb 15, 2018 0 Comments
As an artist, Craig “KR” Costello saw a need for efficient graffiti mediums. As a businessperson, he solved the hole in the market.   Graffiti artists in New York were all about mobility, painting subway cars through the City...
Go to full post
Music and Resilience in Osceola County
Feb 13, 2018 0 Comments
In the aftermath of the hurricanes that struck Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, over 2,300 students have been relocated to Florida. In Osceola County, arts educators and business leaders are partnering to provide support for...
Go to full post
Interested in measuring business support for the arts in your community?
Jan 23, 2018 0 Comments
Since 1969, Americans for the Arts through the Business Committee for the Arts (BCA), has been conducting the National Survey of Business Support for the Arts. Now, conducted annually in partnership with The Conference Board...
Go to full post
New David Rockefeller BCA pARTnership Award
Jan 08, 2018 0 Comments
Americans for the Arts announced today that the David Rockefeller Fund will invest in a four-year presenting sponsorship of the new David Rockefeller BCA pARTnership Award. Given annually, the award will honor a company and arts...
Go to full post
Nation's United Arts Funds Raise $85.5 million for the Arts in 2016
Jan 02, 2018 0 Comments
Throughout the summer of 2017, the Americans for the Arts Private Sector Initiatives department solicited responses to the FY2016 United Arts Fund Campaign Survey. Surveys were distributed to a total of 45 united arts funds by...
Go to full post
Nominate the Best Businesses Partnering with the Arts
Dec 11, 2017 0 Comments
CALL FOR NOMINATIONS: 2018 BCA 10 AWARDS Every year, Americans for the Arts through its Business Committee for the Arts, honors the 10 best businesses partnering with the arts in America. Submissions close January 19. ...
Go to full post
Award-Winning Examples of Companies Supporting the Arts
Nov 21, 2017 0 Comments
The arts are an economic driver. According to the Arts & Economic Prosperity study, released by Americans for the Arts, the nonprofit arts and culture industry generated $166.3 billion of economic activity during 2015, which...
Go to full post
BCA 10 Spotlight: AC Entertainment in Knoxville, Tennessee
Nov 14, 2017 0 Comments
Known as one of the foremost concert promoters and festival producers in the United States, AC Entertainment celebrates the arts by bringing first-class live entertainment experiences to music lovers from around the world. Founded...
Go to full post
BCA 10 Spotlight: Scholastic Inc., New York City
Nov 09, 2017 0 Comments
“Creative, innovative thinking, the hallmark of artists and writers, is fundamental to building economic strength, and new and better ways of seeing the world. The Scholastic Art & Writing Awards validates the creativity of students...
Go to full post

Already a partner?

Already a partner?

Learn easy ways to take your partnership to a new level.

Use our ads locally

Use our ads locally

View The pARTnership Movement ad campaign and find ways to use the ads.

pARTnership videos

pARTnership videos

Watch and share our videos from The pARTnership Movement.

Partnership ideas

Partnership ideas

Inspire employees with tickets to the ballet or a concert.

Are you an arts group?

Are you an arts group?

Get listed in our searchable directory.

Recruit talent

Recruit talent

Employees want to live and work in a vibrant community.